GDG- RE: Vincent Position
GEODEUTSCH at aol.com
GEODEUTSCH at aol.com
Mon Jul 7 13:03:32 CDT 2008
There have been several posts concerning Strong Vincent and his brigade
prior to moving to LRT.
"... Where was Strong Vincent (and his Brigade) when he met the courier from
Gen. Warren and then took responsibility to go to Little Round Top? Is an
exact position known?..."
"...The entire brigade may have been in the Wheatfield, but Zack could also
be correct. If they were the lead brigade of the division, where were the
following brigades? Wouldn't the following brigades been closer to the courier
than Vincent? How is it that he was approached first?..."
Zack's response was essentially correct: "Vincent's brigade was in defilade
west of the George Weikert farm,
with Vincent personally riding in the direction of the Wheatfield at the
time of his being intercepted by Capt. Jay of Sykes' staff."
There are several Weikert farms in the area, the one where Vincent and Jay
met is northeast of the Wheatfield across the Wheatfield Road.
Vincent himself was leading the First Division of Fifth Corps, General James
Barnes (the temporary commander replacing Charles Griffin who was recovering
from a wound) was not with the column. It is commonly alleged that Barnes
was somewhere drunk. Judging by his later decisions after he did show up in the
Wheatfield, the charge of drunkenness seems likely true. Vincent's Third
Brigade led the column, followed by Tilton & Sweitzer.
According to Vincent's aide and brigade bugler, Oliver Norton, while the
division was halted short of the Wheatfield, Vincent saw a rider (Sykes's aide)
approaching and rode out to meet him. After taking personal responsibility
to occupy LRT, Vincent turned his own brigade towards LRT, while the other
two brigades headed to their meeting with Kershaw on Stony Hill.
Here are a few subsequent interesting facts about Vincent:
Vincent & Norton rode ahead of the brigade up onto LRT. The horsemen
attracted so much Confederate artillery fire that Vincent ordered Norton, who was
carrying the brigade flag, to take the horses and the flag to the backside of
the hill, while Vincent scouted where to place his troops.
Vincent left his sword on his horse, so carried only his wife's riding crop
during the fight.
Vincent formed the brigade line in an inverse U shape along the military
summit, now known as Vincent's Spur. He made his headquarters in the center of
the line, behind and uphill from his old regiment, the 83rd Penna. Today's
visitor to LRT can see the HQ position marked by the white, tombstone looking
marker which reads "Gen. Strong Vincent Wounded July 2, Died July 7, 1863".
There is a common misconception that Vincent was wounded at the spot where
the marker stands. He was actually taken there after his wounding before being
moved to the Jacob Weikert farmhouse on the reverse side of LRT.
This marker was erected by the veterans of the 83rd and was the first
permanent monument on the battlefield outside of the National Cemetery. The
original was vandalized in the 1970s and was replaced by the current one. The
original marker is now on loan to the Erie County (PA) Library and is on display
there.
Vincent was actually wounded on the west face of LRT behind the line of the
fractured 16th Michigan while rallying those troops. He stood on a boulder
brandishing his riding crop while ordering the men "Don't give an inch, boys!"
There are conflicting reports saying he was shot either while on the rock or
had just stepped off of it.
Visitors can see the boulder, which is directly north of the 44th NY's
"castle" monument. In the late afternoon on a sunny day, you can still make out
the faint inscription, which was carved in it near the time of the battle:
"Col. Strong Vincent fell here Com 3rd Brig. 1st Div. 5 Corps July 2nd 1863."
Although his wounding has been commonly attributed to a "sharpshooter" from
Devil's Den, it is more likely that he was shot from below by one of the
Texans assaulting the hill.
Vincent entered the Battle of Gettysburg as a Colonel but was singled out
for promotion to Brigadier General by General Meade in a telegram to Lincoln
the night of July 2nd. Meade knew that Vincent was mortally wounded, but told
the President of Vincent's Gettysburg actions and of his leadership on other
fields. Lincoln promoted Vincent to the full rank of Brigadier, not by Brevet.
Lincoln's order reached Vincent before he died on July 7th, but there has
been much conjecture whether Vincent was actually aware of the promotion before
his death.
Vincent's wife Elizabeth gave birth to their only child two months later,
but the baby girl died just short of her first birthday. Elizabeth never
remarried. All three are buried together in the Erie Cemetery.
Vincent's sword is in the Smithsonian, his bible is on display in his
parish, St. Paul's in Erie but unfortunately neither the riding crop nor his
letters to Elizabeth survive today.
George Deutsch
**************Gas prices getting you down? Search AOL Autos for
fuel-efficient used cars. (http://autos.aol.com/used?ncid=aolaut00050000000007)
More information about the Gettysburg
mailing list