GDG- Ewell and the high ground (more questions for discussion)

[James Cameron]

<< Therefore, my opinion is that Early/Ewell probably could not have taken
either hill on the evening of July 1.  There was a substantial Union
artillery force on Cemetery Hill after the retreat through town, as well as
both organized and fairly disorganized infantry.  The north side of Culp's
Hill was defended by the remnants of the Iron Brigade (I Corps), battered
but still a fighting force. Since most of the CSA was in town, the attack
would have to come from in the town if it were to get under way before dark.
Can you imagine trying to organize a line of battle in all the streets and
alleys of Gettysburg before moving out against Cemetery Hill?  >>

Good analysis Jack.

Bottom line, even with knowledge of the Union strength and positions on the 
two hills, I just don't think Ewell's corps would have been able to mount 
and launch an adequately planned, strong and coordinated enough attack to 
have a convincing chance of taking either hill, this late in the day.

Jim Cameron

"It is in truth not for glory, nor riches, nor honours that we are fighting, 
but for freedom - and for that alone, which no honest man gives up but with 
life itself."
>From the Declaration of Arbroath.