GDG- 69th PA
elcarto at comcast.net
elcarto at comcast.net
Sat Jan 6 18:33:14 CST 2007
>According to Busey and Martins work, Gettysburg strengths and losses, the
69th loses 137. Obviously they did not suffer this amount during the charge.
>So where did they? - Jim Lamason
Just to play Devil's advocate for a second, why would you say that it's "obvious' that they didn't suffer the bulk of their casualties during 'the charge'? On July 3rd they were in the epicenter of a much larger and more concentrated attack than occured on July 2nd, regardless of what you or I think about the exact placement of the latter. Therefore it stands to reason that they would have suffered the bulk of theio casualties on July 3rd, absent any definate account that they were in as likewise heavy a combat on the second.
Most of the evidence that's been presented here seems to show that their casualties on July 2nd were relatively light, and concentrated in the left most companies. Which would seem to support the 'conventional wisdom', that has Wright hitting just south of them, with only his left coming into contact with the left of the 69th, roughly in front of the 'Copse of trees'.
Rick Barber
More information about the Gettysburg
mailing list