GDG- Winter Stomp

[James Cameron]

<< > the sector between the grove and Arnold's position
> became Smyth's, and was so by the time the action progressed up the that
> sector.  And nothing in any of the accounts from the brigade covering the
> afternoon's action suggests anything even remotely like your scenario.
>

I will add that none of the accounts from the Fourteenth Connecticut 
Infantry
of Smyth's brigade even hint at an assault on their position along Cemetery
Ridge on the 2nd, let along being overrun.  And I have read a good many 14 
CVI
accounts, including those written for publication and some for private
consumption only.

Bruce Trinque >>

Which is why  it's not correct to say there are only two Union accounts from 
the sector between Arnold's battery and the Zeigler's Grove.  There are 
numerous reports and accounts, from Smyth's brigade, not one of which even 
hints at a Confederate breakthrough or or the batteries being overrun.

Jim Cameron