GDG- war weariness of the public
Biggsk at aol.com
Biggsk at aol.com
Fri Feb 2 00:33:11 CST 2007
Folks,
I just recalled this, a couple years or so ago, I watched a show on the
History Channel about the last year of World War 2 - 1945.
According to the show, despite our victory over Germany, the prospect of a
massive shifting of our troops from Europe to the Pacific to fight Japan was
indeed on everyone's minds. War-weariness had indeed hit the American people
to some degree (thankfully, we never came close to the massive casualties
suffered by the Soviets, or that would have come much sooner). The USA's
treasury was basically run dry.
Then came the win on Iwo Jima (itself now being re-examined to determine of
it was even necessary to attack it - a recent essay in MHQ covers this), and
it so electrified the American people, that a new war bond drive was launched
and enough money raised to finish the war - as it was.
Note that this does not take into account what would have happened had we
actually needed to invade Japan. Our war plans called for one invasion in late
1945 and another in 1946. Declassified Japanese sources show just how
strong their home island defenses were and that they did still have thousands of
aircraft hidden away just for this. If we think Iwo Jima and Okinawa were
blood-baths, the home islands would have been worse. The estimated prospect of
a million casualties (both sides) was not out of the realm of possibility.
Would the American public have stood for this had the atomic bombs not been
developed or used?
By 1945 we had the most powerful air force the world had ever seen. We had
the most powerful navy the world had ever seen and our army was only exceeded
by that of the Soviet Union. We had just marched from North Africa to close
to Berlin and from Hawaii to close to Iwo Jima - and yet the American people
were growing tired of the war and its costs.
I use this point to counter what Laurie has stated about the similar events
of the Civil War, that despite the fact that the Union had taken much of the
South by 1864, there was still a chance they could lose. What saved us in
World War 2 (in the Pacific at least), if this show is accurate, was the win at
Iwo Jima. What saved Lincoln, was the win at Atlanta, and then a couple
other smaller ones for good measure.
Greg Biggs
More information about the Gettysburg
mailing list