GDG- The Battle Between the Lanes

[Alan D. Brunelle]

I'd have to heartily agree with Phil's sentiments - I'm working my way 
through the driving/walking tour right now, and I am just having a very 
enjoyable/educational time going through this book. In particular, I 
think chapter 20 "After Thoughts" is one of the best reads I've had in 
quite some time - very well written! I also agree with your points about 
the 111th NY and Hancock - the author's arguments when discussing the 
111th NY and 1st Minn seem very well reasoned.

For me personally, it seems that a lot of books spend a significant 
portion of time on the parts of the battle leading up to the collapse of 
the 3rd Corp (and other elements), and then more briefly discuss the 
concluding parts - I think this book expands very well on that critical 
portion of time.

Regards,
Alan